When it comes to Christmas movies, the classics have set a high bar. “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever,” based on Barbara Robinson’s cherished 1972 novel, swoops in like a delightful wrecking ball, injecting fresh humor, chaos, and a surprisingly poignant message. The movie, directed by Dallas Jenkins, follows the story of the Herdmans—a band of rowdy, unapologetically “worst kids in the world”—as they bulldoze their way into the town’s annual Christmas pageant, much to the horror and bewilderment of the local churchgoing folk.
A Recipe for Chaos: The Plot
Imagine a Christmas pageant at a quaint, small-town church: tranquil, reverent, and slightly predictable. Enter the Herdmans—six siblings with a reputation for mayhem, mischief, and a penchant for chaos. Known for activities like setting fires, stealing lunches, and bullying half the town’s kids, they are the last children anyone would expect to see near a Nativity scene. But through a series of mishaps, the Herdman gang hijacks the main roles in the Christmas pageant, and what ensues is a mix of hilarity, confusion, and unanticipated charm.
As the Herdmans embody Mary, Joseph, and the other Nativity roles in their own “creative” way, the town braces itself for what seems like a holiday disaster. However, as they struggle through rehearsals and playfully reinterpret the Christmas story, the Herdmans bring a refreshingly unfiltered perspective to the pageant, opening the eyes of the audience and, surprisingly, reminding the town of the true essence of Christmas.
The Cast Brings Unexpected Joy
This updated adaptation brings some of today’s beloved comedy actors, led by Judy Greer as Grace Bradley, the well-meaning but exasperated pageant director, and Pete Holmes as her husband, Bob. Greer’s comedic timing and ability to capture a frazzled but loving spirit bring an endearing warmth to Grace. Alongside her, Pete Holmes brings a charming obliviousness to Bob, often caught between supporting his wife’s noble ambitions and the reality of wrangling the Herdman chaos.
Lauren Graham narrates with a wink, bridging scenes with just the right amount of wry humor. The Herdman siblings—played by Beatrice Schneider, Mason Nelligan, and others—each embody their mischievous characters with gusto, and their on-screen chemistry makes them memorable. This ensemble captures the pandemonium, laughter, and unexpected sweetness that Robinson’s story has always promised.
Dallas Jenkins at the Helm
Dallas Jenkins, known for his work on “The Chosen,” injects a modern sensibility into the movie without losing the story’s timeless charm. His experience with character-driven storytelling shines here, as he balances the Herdmans’ antics with heartfelt moments that reflect on community, kindness, and the unexpected ways we find meaning. Jenkins directs with a light but insightful touch, allowing the movie to maintain its humor while hitting poignant notes that elevate it above typical holiday fare.
More Than Just Comedy
Beneath the laughs and misunderstandings, “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” explores how preconceptions and judgments fall apart in the face of genuine humanity. As the Herdmans stumble through the pageant process—learning about Mary, Joseph, and the Christmas story—they inadvertently teach the community what it truly means to celebrate Christmas. In a scene-stealing monologue, Gladys Herdman (played with wit and charm by young Kynlee Heiman) delivers a heartfelt, if slightly “improvised,” reflection on the Nativity, surprising everyone with her sincerity.
While most Christmas movies rely on tidy morals wrapped in a seasonal bow, “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” presents the Christmas spirit with just the right amount of irreverence. It turns tradition on its head, suggesting that the holiday’s true meaning might come through even the most unlikely messengers.
Cinematography and Setting: A Cozy Holiday Ambiance
The cinematography by C. Kim Miles amplifies the film’s cozy, small-town charm. From bustling main streets adorned with Christmas lights to the softly lit church sanctuary, every scene invites the viewer into an almost storybook setting. The visual warmth contrasts cleverly with the Herdmans’ antics, providing the perfect backdrop for their disorderly presence. The art direction and set design echo the classic American holiday look, making the film feel familiar and nostalgic without being overly sentimental.
Why This Movie Stands Out
What makes “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” truly special is its unapologetic embrace of imperfection. The movie doesn’t pretend that the Herdmans are sweet, misunderstood kids. They are terrors—and they’re wonderfully played as such. Yet their unvarnished, unruly approach to the Christmas pageant shakes up the local community in a way that resonates beyond the laughs. By the time the pageant is underway, the audience may find themselves both laughing at and rooting for the Herdmans as they present a version of the Nativity unlike any other.
For audiences weary of predictable holiday tropes, “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” offers a breath of fresh air. It doesn’t try to deliver life lessons with a saccharine touch but instead lets the hilarity and heart come naturally through its eccentric characters and their unintended impact.
Who Will Love This Film?
This adaptation is sure to resonate with families, but it also appeals to fans of lighthearted satire and those looking for a holiday story that feels more grounded and real. Whether viewers are longtime fans of the original book or new to the Herdmans’ antics, they’ll find something to love. The film is a reminder that Christmas isn’t about perfection, and often, the most touching holiday moments come from the most unexpected places.
Final Thoughts on The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
In a season filled with predictable plots and neatly wrapped resolutions, “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” strikes a different chord. With a stellar cast, laugh-out-loud moments, and just enough sentimental charm, the film has all the ingredients for a new holiday favorite. It’s not the typical polished Christmas movie—and that’s precisely why it works. The Herdmans are as far from a Hallmark family as one could imagine, but in their chaos, they capture the unfiltered, messy beauty of community and tradition.
For those seeking holiday cheer with a dose of laughter and a dash of satire, “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” is well worth the watch. It might just become a new Christmas classic that, like the Herdmans themselves, is impossible to ignore.
FAQs
What is “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” about?
This comedy follows the Herdman kids, a group of troublemakers who disrupt their town’s Christmas pageant, only to end up bringing an unexpected charm and a fresh perspective on the holiday season.
Who stars in “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
The cast includes Judy Greer, Pete Holmes, Lauren Graham as the narrator, and a group of talented child actors portraying the Herdmans.
Is “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever” family-friendly?
Yes, it’s rated PG. While it includes light thematic material and brief underage smoking, it’s appropriate for most families and delivers heartwarming moments.
Who directed “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
Dallas Jenkins, known for “The Chosen,” directed the film, bringing his character-focused storytelling style to the holiday movie.
What is the release date for “The Best Christmas Pageant Ever”?
The movie premieres in theaters on November 8, 2024.
Is this movie based on a book?
Yes, it’s based on the classic children’s novel by Barbara Robinson, beloved for its humor and unique take on the holiday spirit.
