Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s Authority Over Oregon National Guard, Though Portland Deployment Remains Blocked
In a significant legal development, the Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s authority to command Oregon National Guard troops. However, a separate lower court order continues to prevent their deployment, creating a persistent legal stalemate regarding this domestic deployment.
The 9th Circuit Decision: How the Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s Federalization Authority
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, in a 2-1 decision, overturned a part of a district court ruling that had previously barred President Trump from federalization of approximately 200 Oregon National Guard soldiers. The appellate court affirmed that the administration was likely to prevail in its claim of statutory authority, suggesting the President lawfully exercised his powers under Title 10 U.S. Code to bring the Guard under federal control. This particular Appeals Court ruling means the Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s broader claim of authority over the Trump National Guard.
The judges indicated that existing law does not restrict the circumstances a President can consider when deciding to deploy soldiers domestically. They also stated that the lower court had not given sufficient deference to the President’s determination that federal law could not otherwise be enforced.
This ruling is the latest in ongoing legal battles initiated by the city of Portland and the state of Oregon concerning the extent of presidential authority in domestic deployments, with the Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s federalization claim. The Federal Appeals Court Allows Oregon National Guard Federalization, Deployment to Portland Remains Blocked, underscoring the ongoing legal complexities after the Appeals Court ruling.
Background of the Dispute
President Trump announced his intention to deploy federalized National Guard troops to Portland in late September. He cited ongoing unrest in the city and the need to protect federal property and personnel, particularly at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE facilities). Trump controversially described Portland as “war-ravaged” and under siege by “antifa thugs.” These assertions were strongly disputed by local and state officials, who contested the factual basis for such claims. The context for this Trump National Guard issue is that the Appeals Court Greenlights Trump’s asserted right to use federal powers.
Initial Restraining Orders
U.S. District Judge Karin Immergut, appointed by Trump, initially issued two temporary restraining orders. The first order explicitly prohibited President Trump from calling up the Oregon National Guard for domestic deployment to Portland. Judge Immergut found that the Trump administration had failed to present a legitimate basis for federalizing the troops. She characterized the protest activity in Portland as generally peaceful and involving small numbers by late September, deeming it insufficient justification for federal intervention. Judge Immergut explicitly noted that Trump’s justifications were “simply untethered to the facts.” This is consistent with the later ruling that a Federal Judge Blocks Trump’s National Guard Deployment to Portland, Citing Lack of Factual Basis.
Following Immergut’s initial order, the Trump administration’s Justice Department appealed. In an attempt to bypass the first order, the administration…
Related reading
- Oregon’s Mild Fire Season in 2025: More Fires, Less Burned Acreage Amidst Aggressive Containment Efforts
- Oregon’s 2025 Fire Season: More Ignitions, Dramatically Less Acreage Burned Thanks to Aggressive Tactics and Favorable Conditions
- Federal Judge Extends Block on National Guard Deployment to Portland, Citing Lack of Factual Basis
- Federal Judge Extends Block on National Guard Deployment to Portland by Two Weeks Amid Ongoing Legal Battle
Related reading
- Appeals Court Ruling on Portland National Guard Deployment Imminent Amidst Legal Firestorm
- Federal Appeals Court Allows Oregon National Guard Federalization, Deployment to Portland Remains Blocked
- Oregon Governor Tina Kotek Battles Trump Administration Over Federal National Guard Deployment to Portland
- Oregon Governor Kotek Battles President Trump Over Federal National Guard Deployment to Portland
